Grading Watches 
by Dell Deaton
 

 

Image: Dial closeup on my Omega Seamaster 2254.50 (2005)TinderBox Press publishes each year its Complete Price Guide to Watches, authored by Cooksey Shugart with co-authors Tom Engle and Richard E. Gilbert.

By way of introduction to its 10,350 watches listed in the 2006 edition, this premier text includes the following "grading system" which I highly recommend in assessing watches.

bullet

G-10: 100% — Pristine Mint. New old stock. Absolutely factory new; unused in factory box with wax paper still intact and all tags and papers, etc. The pristine mint grade ... command significant premiums.

bullet

G-9: 99% — Mint Plus. Still in factory box. Exceptional, perfect.

bullet

G-8: 97% — Mint. Same as factory new but with very little use. No faint scratches and no trace of a screwdriver mark; is original in every way, crystal, hands, dial, case, movement; used briefly and stored away, may still be in box. Dealers "Trade Show Price" after overhaul.

bullet

G-7: 93% — Near mint. Completely original in every way; faint marks may be seen with loupe only; expertly repaired; movement may have been cleaned and oiled (excellent).

bullet

G-6: 87% — Extra Fine. May or may not be in factory box; looks as though watch was used very little; original case, hands, dial, and movement. If watch has been repaired, all original replacement parts have been used. Faint case scratches are evident but hard to detect with the eye. No dents and no hairline on dial are detectable.

bullet

G-5: 80% — Fine. May have new hands and new crystal, but original case, dial and movement; faint hairline and no chips on dial; no large scratches and no brass seen on case; slight stain on movement; movement must be sharp with only minor scratches.

bullet

G-4: 75% — Average. Original case, dial and movement; movement may have had apart replaced, but part was near to original; no brass showing through on gold-filled case; no rust or chips in dial; may have hairlines in dial that are hard to see. Marks are hard to detect, but may be seen without a loupe.

bullet

G-3: 60% — Fair. Hairlines in dial and small chips; slight amount of brass can be seen through worn spots on gold-filled case; rust marks in movement; a small dent in case; wear in case, dial, and movement; well used; may not have original dial or case.

bullet

G-2: 30% — Poor. Watch not working; needs new dial; case well worn, many dents; hands may be gone; replacement crystal may be needed.

bullet

G-1: 15% — Scrap. Movement not working; bad dial; rusty movement; brass showing badly; may not have case; some parts not original; no crystal or hands. Good for parts only.

 
 

 
 

 
 

Complete List of pages related to this topic

 
 

Casino Royale / James Bond Omega Blog12/22/2006News and thoughts on "Casino Royale"
COSC Testing01/03/2006Official Swiss Chronometer Testing Institute
Grading Watches02/13/2006Shugart, Gilbert, Engle Criteria (2006)
Grading Watches from Film Props04/02/2006Exclusive
James Bond Limited Omega 2537.8011/15/2006Reference details
James Bond's Omega 2541.8002/14/2006Quartz Seamaster Watch
Omega 2254.50 Watch Photos09/07/2006Digital image gallery
Omega 2531.80 Watch Photos10/01/2006Digital image gallery
Omega 2537.80 Watch Photo References01/01/2008Digital image gallery
Omega 2907.50.91 Watch Photo References01/01/2008
Omega 2907.50.91 Watch Photos01/02/2008
Omega Seamaster01/10/2008Introduction to my Omega Seamaster watch interests
Omega Water Test01/03/2006Description and service intervals
Precision Accuracy01/05/2006Performance standards compared
Rolex 14060M Watch Photos09/07/2006Digital image gallery
Rolex 16610 Watch Photos09/18/2006Digital image gallery
Seiko M354-5019 Watch Photos01/05/2008
Time Piece Links03/10/2006URLs for content not on my website
Time Pieces01/03/2006Introduction to my watch, clock, and time keeping interests
Wearing a Watch Like James Bond03/19/2006Overview page

 
 
 
 
   
Copyright © 2008-2005 Dell Deaton. All Rights Reserved. Ann Arbor, Michigan (USA). Nothing on this site may be used in whole or in part without express written permission from its owner, in advance. Visitors to this site assume all risk for any and all use thereof; no warranty of any kind is provided, expressed or implied.
 

v 2.056