Precision Accuracy 
by Dell Deaton
 

 

Photo: Close-up of Omega Seamaster watch winding, setting crown (2000 model)Precision and accuracy aren't the same thing.

As Alan Downing points out in his "Inside COSC" article for TimeZone:

"...a watch that gains 15 seconds a day might not be accurate, but if it gains (or loses) exactly the same amount every day, it is extremely precise.

"High precision can be adjusted to accuracy, but low precision indicates inherent faults...."

So much for those nincompoops fond of mindlessly insisting, "The most accurate watch is a stopped watch."

Omega definition of "chronometer"

bullet

Variation of between not more than -4 and +6 seconds per day

bullet

This equates to a 99.99% precision

Omega mechanical watch design standard

bullet

Variation of between not more than -1 and +6 seconds per day

In evaluating my own Omega watches, timekeeping accuracy must average a daily variation of not more than -1 and +6 seconds per day — over the course of a 15-day comparison against the US Navel Observatory Master Clock.  Bluntly put, this is part of the performance guarantee I am purchasing from Omega, based on its own representations.

Mechanical watches without certificates

bullet

"The majority ... have average precision tolerances of between -1 and +11 seconds per day," according to Omega

Omega quartz movements

bullet

Accurate to within "variations of between -0.5 and +0.7 seconds per day."

By my math, that makes a quartz movement somewhere between 1½ and 12 times as accurate as its COSC-certified mechanical counterpart.

 

 
 

 
 

Complete List of pages related to this topic

 
 

Casino Royale / James Bond Omega Blog12/22/2006News and thoughts on "Casino Royale"
COSC Testing01/03/2006Official Swiss Chronometer Testing Institute
Grading Watches02/13/2006Shugart, Gilbert, Engle Criteria (2006)
Grading Watches from Film Props04/02/2006Exclusive
James Bond Limited Omega 2537.8011/15/2006Reference details
James Bond's Omega 2541.8002/14/2006Quartz Seamaster Watch
Omega 2254.50 Watch Photos09/07/2006Digital image gallery
Omega 2531.80 Watch Photos10/01/2006Digital image gallery
Omega 2537.80 Watch Photo References01/01/2008Digital image gallery
Omega 2907.50.91 Watch Photo References01/01/2008
Omega 2907.50.91 Watch Photos01/02/2008
Omega Seamaster01/10/2008Introduction to my Omega Seamaster watch interests
Omega Water Test01/03/2006Description and service intervals
Precision Accuracy01/05/2006Performance standards compared
Rolex 14060M Watch Photos09/07/2006Digital image gallery
Rolex 16610 Watch Photos09/18/2006Digital image gallery
Seiko M354-5019 Watch Photos01/05/2008
Time Piece Links03/10/2006URLs for content not on my website
Time Pieces01/03/2006Introduction to my watch, clock, and time keeping interests
Wearing a Watch Like James Bond03/19/2006Overview page

 
 
 
 
   
Copyright © 2008-2005 Dell Deaton. All Rights Reserved. Ann Arbor, Michigan (USA). Nothing on this site may be used in whole or in part without express written permission from its owner, in advance. Visitors to this site assume all risk for any and all use thereof; no warranty of any kind is provided, expressed or implied.
 

v 2.056